Our Story

South Rim Realty has been in business in Payson, Utah since 1983. The current owners, Gayle Baum and Lindsey Andrus, took over the business in 2005. In their 10+ years as brokers, Gayle and Lindsey have grown the agent portfolio to 12 agents. The majority of the agents at South Rim Realty are local: they know the area, they’ve grown up in Utah County, and they have long-term relationships with many of their clients.

South Rim Realty is a full-service company. Let them help you with all of your real estate needs!

Our Promise

South Rim Realty is committed to your real estate success.

I promise to keep you in the loop and the lines of communication open.”

– Communication is fundamental to a working buying or selling relationship; a great real estate agent knows questions will come and that the buyer or seller needs direction as soon as possible. You should never feel your agent is MIA (missing in action).

I promise you this is my full-time career.

– Experienced real estate agents have graduated from the part-timer’s realm to the ability to support themselves with their income in real estate. People are pros when they go full-time.

“I promise to give you honest advice.”

– Professional real estate agents are concerned, engaged, and provide the best counsel when it comes to serving your real estate needs. We know that sometimes this advice may not be easy to hear, especially when it comes to pricing, budget, or repairs. We want to help you make the best real estate decisions.

Meet the Team

Gayle Baum

Information coming soon!

Lindsey Andrus

Information coming soon!

Alan Carter

Having been in the Real Estate business for 21 years, lifelong resident of Genola and a former General Contract owner, Alan specializes in the sale of new and existing homes in South Utah County area.

Leveraging on his experience as a successful business owner, Alan is known as a skilled negotiator with his client’s best interest at heart. He believes strongly that is not only his duty to represent his clients to the best of his ability, but to educate them throughout every step of the process armed with top notched information and market insight. Alan wants his clients to make the best decision possible.

The motto Alan adheres to and strongly believes in is,

“People don’t care how much you know until they know how much you care.”

In his free time Alan likes to golf, spend time with his family and take short day trips with his wife.

Dennis DeGraw

I have lived in Utah County between Payson and Salem for most of my life. I love this area, its beauty and the people that live here. I love the outdoors and enjoy camping, fishing and hunting with family and friends. I am married to the love of my life Angie, and together we have 6 children, 5 in-law children, and 11 grandchildren. All of which are Awesome!

I have been in real estate for over 25 years. As a real estate professional, I specialize in helping families and individuals buy and sell homes and property. I have worked in the good markets and the down and distressed markets. I have worked with banks and clients to sell and buy foreclosure homes. I have also been successful in negotiating short sales with many banks on behalf of my sellers. I have helped many of my clients buy distressed properties.

For the last 22 years I have been hired by Utah County to help with the Board of Equalization as an impartial hearing officer to help establish fair market values. Every year the county sends you an Evaluation Notice of what they feel your home, land, or any real estate you own is worth. If you cannot come to an agreement with the appraiser at the assessor’s office as to the value of your property, then the county will set up a hearing time for you to meet with a hearing officer. That is where I would come in. At the hearing I would listen to both the property owner and to the county appraiser and review all documentation and evidence from both parties as to their appeal of value. I would then make a determination of what I felt a fair market value would be based upon all documentation. I have been involved with hundreds of hearings over the years in every part of Utah County and in every city. I have been fair in all cases and gained much knowledge during the process.

With extensive knowledge of the Utah real estate market, I would be delighted to put my experience and expertise to work for you. If you are in the market to buy or sell a home, land, or commercial properties then give me a call or text today. I would be happy to answer any of your questions and provide you with a complete market analysis. Let me help your real estate wants and needs become a reality!

Kelly Staheli

Kelly Staheli has lived in Genola his whole life and is married to Amy. They have 5 children. He has been involved in the construction industry in some way over the past 20 years and decided to try Real Estate.

He is especially interested in the property management side of things, and he enjoys fixing things and making them better.

Gary Carter

Gary has been married to his bride, Loretta, for 51 years. They have 5 children and 14 beautiful grandchildren.

Gary was raised on a farm and knows how to work and get the job done. He graduated from BYU with a bachelor’s degree in Sociology, and even owned the Red Wing Shoe Store in Orem for a time.

After 20 years in construction, he decided to try real estate and has been enjoying it for the past 15 years. He is always helpful and great for a good joke or story.

Lorelei Gunn

Born and raised in California, Lorelei and her husband Bill moved to Utah in January 2019.  They choose Payson because the hills behind their home remind them of the bluffs they left behind in the mountains of California where she worked full time and raised Pygmy/Nigerian Dwarf Goats.

They are the proud parents of one son and two amazing grandsons, whom Lorelei calls her “world” and says that nothing keeps you younger than living life through the eyes of a child.

She enjoys walking, hiking, reading and looks forward to exploring all the opportunities Utah has to offer.

Dustin Magoffin

Dustin Magoffin was born and raised in Utah. Over the course of the past 6 years, he was worked for two Utah Law Enforcement Agencies. Acquiring special skills in defensive tactics, communication, and conflict resolution.

Due to Dustin’s exceptional interpersonal communication and leadership skills, he was able to join the South Rim team and gained valuable experience as a Sales Associate and now as a licensed Real Estate Agent.

With Dustin’s proven aptitude, ability, and expertise, eh’s been able to prove time and time again the passion, knowledge and motivation that ties him to the community.

Dustin has the ability to speak and conduct business in Spanish.

Patty Magoffin

Patty Magoffin epitomizes integrity, energy, and creative service in every detail of your real estate transaction. Patty grew up in the Payson area and started her sales habit at the early age of 18 knocking doors and selling security systems in Utah, Texas and Maryland neighborhood’s.

Patty is a woman with a devotion to God, her high school sweetheart husband, and their three children. She has been trained and inspired in sales by some of the best. She strives to build strong relationships and is continually furthering her education, and sharpening her skills by attending trainings, workshops as well as seminars. Patty uses her experience and foresight to proactively address details before they become a problem by initiating communication in every detail of the transaction from the first phone call all the way to close.

Gary Bushnell

I am a native to Utah county growing up in Mapleton, Springville area and moving to Payson 34 years ago. I spent my younger days working in construction and concrete delivery which lead me to a dispatching and driver supervisory position that I held for 17 years. This position, working with employees and customers not only helped me to become very familiar with the Utah county area and the different communities, but I also learned communication skills that are proving valuable when assisting clients with their real estate needs. I have helped numerous families relocate into this area from other states. I have now been a part of South Rim Realty group for the past 10 years and appreciate everyone’s attitudes, professionalism and work ethic. I am committed to my client’s best interest and find it very enjoyable and satisfying to help them through the buying or sell process.

Jairo Uribe

Jairo Uribe has been passionate about real estate since his earliest years growing up in Utah County. Jairo always knew that he wanted to chart a path helping others and found his true calling in real estate serving clients and guiding them through one of the biggest investments of their lives. With his past experiences, Jairo has prepared and studied diligently the latest market conditions to overcome any challenge ahead of him. Jairo feels incredibly blessed to work with amazing clients who become friends and a strong part of his network.

Ariel Martinez

Information coming soon!

Ready to get started?